Blessed Brother James Miller answered the Lasallian call with a life of faith, service and courageous witness
Father Alan Guanella
Vicar General and Judicial Vicar of the Diocese of La Crosse
Born and raised in Ellis, Wis., just outside of Stevens Point, Blessed Brother James Miller was a member of the Institute of the Brothers of the Christian Schools, commonly known as the Christian Brothers. He was martyred in Guatemala in 1982 and beatified in December 2019.
The Heroic Vow
The Christian Brothers were founded by the French priest St. John Baptist de La Salle and officially approved in 1725. One well-known part of the Christian Brothers’ history has come to be called the “heroic vow.”
We go back to 1691. De La Salle was in a moment of difficulty. The community of teaching brothers he had formed a decade before was falling apart. As one author notes, he was in the throes of indecision as to whether or not to continue this seemingly foolish enterprise. Brothers were dying from exhaustion. Many had left the rigor of his fledgling community. He was ridiculed by the local church and terribly misunderstood by his own family.
On Nov. 21, 1691, De La Salle, along with Brothers Nicholas Vuyart and Gabriel Drolin, gathered in secret and made a vow to God that they would remain together in the society even if they would have to beg and live on bread alone. This was the heroic vow.
God heard the prayers of De La Salle, Vuyart and Drolin, and the community of brothers flourished. It should come as no surprise, then, that the motto of the Christian Brothers is Signum Fidei, “Sign of Faith.”
Brother James Miller would have known well the motto of his institute. Perhaps he thought of these words when reading one of the Meditations of De La Salle, in which the founder writes, “God has chosen you to make Him known to others.” As we honor Blessed Brother James Miller throughout our diocese, we celebrate a person chosen by God not only to assist the poor, oppressed and uneducated in the world but also to make God known to others. In other words, to be a “sign of faith” in the world.




Faith and Zeal
With the heroic vow in mind, one understands why a significant part of Lasallian spirituality is a focus on faith and zeal. The heroic vow itself was an act of faith and zeal. The 1718 Rule of the Christian Brothers, notes Brother Charles Hilken, FSC, describes faith as the first great gift to the brothers, one that induces them to look upon everything they do in their work in light of their relationship with God. Zeal, their second special gift, is a burning desire for the instruction and spiritual welfare of their students.
In a meditation on the feast of St. Andrew, De La Salle writes, “You are called like the apostles to make God known, and for that purpose you need great zeal.” Brother James desired to go to Central America to minister to the indigenous people there, knowing full well that Nicaragua in the 1970s and Guatemala in the 1980s were not safe places to be.
For the Christian Brothers, the spirit of faith implies the zeal to instruct youth. Brother James was not content to live a life where things were easy; he was ready to go where things were difficult. In fact, after returning from Nicaragua, during his years teaching at Cretin High School in St. Paul, Brother James wrote, “The weather hasn’t been so cold this year, so I’ve managed. I hate snow, even the little we’ve gotten this year. […] I guess it’s no secret that I am anxious to return to Latin America.”
Where Things Were Difficult
As we know, Brother James’ ministry in Central America was not without difficulty. During the violent clashes in Nicaragua in the 1970s, he wrote, “The entire country is passing through some difficult days … Pray for us and the people we serve.” In Guatemala, Brother James noted that “[t]he level of personal violence here is reaching appalling proportions, and the Church is being persecuted because of its option for the poor and oppressed.”
While he stated that he was personally weary of violence, he continued to feel a strong commitment to the suffering poor of Central America. Whether he knew it or not, he was living the advice De La Salle gave his teachers: “Leave aside all your worry about the present and all your anxiety about the future; occupy yourselves with what you have to do at each moment as it is given to you, and do not burden the day which is passing with doubts about the day to follow.”
Abandoned to Providence
It was there in Guatemala, on the afternoon of Feb. 13, 1982, while Brother James was fixing a lamp on the outside wall of the house, that he was shot and martyred. In his martyrdom, Brother James showed the same heroism that De La Salle, Vuyart and Drolin had when they made the heroic vow in 1691.
It is clear that Brother James took to heart the words De La Salle wrote to Drolin in 1705: that we “must abandon ourselves entirely to [Divine] Providence.” Brother James’ trust in Divine Providence becomes for us a sign of faith.
Signs of Faith Today
Faith and zeal are the hallmarks of the spirit of the Christian Brothers. Brother Maurice Hermans, FSC, explains faith and zeal as “a relationship between two elements of one spirit, a relationship of cause to effect. The spirit of faith is the source, and the spirit of zeal is one of its essential manifestations, one of the necessary effects.”
When the Church beatified Brother James Miller in 2019, it affirmed that Brother James had faith, and we saw that faith manifested through his zeal. So strong were his faith and zeal, in fact, that he was martyred for them.
As the Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches, all Christians are impelled by their duty to take part in the life of the Church and to act as witnesses of the Gospel. “This witness is a transmission of the faith in words and deeds.” Martyrdom, consequently, is “the supreme witness given to the truth of the faith,” and “the martyr bears witness to Christ who died and rose, to whom he is united by charity.” (CCC 2472-2473)
As we celebrate Brother James’ life, we ask for his intercession so that we might be witnesses of the Gospel, just as he was. Like Brother James, we too must be signs of faith to all in the world.
In his remarks at Brother James’ funeral at Sacred Heart Church in Polonia, Bishop Frederick Freking, then bishop of La Crosse, noted, “I see in Brother James’ death the witness of Christ’s love, a witness to the dignity of the human person, and the right to freedom and justice that should be all of ours. Today we need to take a stand on these rights, especially for the poor.” We all must be a witness, a Sign of Faith, to the dignity of the human person today.
This may seem like a daunting task. I am sure that it seemed that way for Brother James. In fact, Brother James once said in a conversation, “You can’t waste your energies worrying about what might happen. If it happens, it happens.” De La Salle, almost as if speaking directly to Brother James, once remarked: “God knows what you are capable of, and He is not going to command you things above your strength. If indeed they are difficult in themselves, it is up to Him to impart to you the ability you need to carry them out.”
