Anne McMenomy-Rodman thought God’s call might come with easier speech, less fear and a body that hurts less. Instead, she discovered that God was not waiting for a more perfect version of her.
Story by Erik Archer
There is a moment, maybe half a second long, when Anne McMenomy-Rodman knows
a word is not going to come.
She is in a room at St. Patrick Parish in Onalaska in front of a dozen confirmation students, mid-sentence, and somewhere ahead in the sentence she has committed to, a word is waiting that she can feel is going to cause a stumble. So, she goes looking for another one, rerouting while she is still talking, hunting a synonym that carries the same meaning without costing her the same fight. She does it without breaking stride, several times an hour, every day she teaches.
She has spent a lifetime simultaneously navigating the present and future tense of every conversation. Other kids sometimes teased her for her stutter, and she was even occasionally marked down on presentations at school for a thing she can no more control than the color of her eyes. Although she was active in theater and speech competitions while growing up, the experiences weren’t helpful later in life when Anne needed to speak words that were not completely memorized over weeks of careful practice.
By adulthood, she had built a private infrastructure of substitutions and workarounds and reached a reasonable conclusion: whatever she did, it should not involve talking to groups.
So you may be surprised to learn that Anne is the director of religious education and youth ministry at St. Patrick Parish in Onalaska.






The words that fight hardest
Her position requires Anne to teach the Catholic Faith and, in the ordinary course of a week, talk to a great many people about Jesus. Consider, then, what it means that one of the words Anne cannot reliably say is “baptism.”
She has a technique for it. Rather than approach the word cold, she gathers speed and rolls through it inside a longer phrase, letting the momentum of the sacrament of baptism carry her over.
Another word that causes a stumble? “Catholic.”
At this point, it becomes a losing battle to keep a straight face, and Anne doesn’t try. She laughs easily. Another? “People.” She avoids it so consistently that folks have quietly replaced it in her working vocabulary. The folks in her parish. The folks at Mass. The folks she is preparing for the sacraments.
“Half of the words I normally use!” she exclaims. And then a look of surprise and joy flashes across Anne’s face as she remembers one more word that consistently causes her to stumble … a name that comes up now and then in her line of work.
“Jesus.”
G.K. Chesterton tells us the angels can fly because they take themselves lightly. A woman is called to spend her life speaking about the Catholic Faith, and the words that fight her hardest are “Catholic,” “baptism,” “people” and “Jesus.” Anne has landed on finding that funny, which is its own kind of theological achievement.
Of course, for most of her life, Anne felt that her stutter closed doors. Then she felt God calling her through one of them.
Jesus on the shelf
Anne grew up in a Catholic family that went to Mass every Sunday, said grace before meals and prayed morning and night, and she attended Catholic school from preschool through 12th grade. “We were the family that did all the Catholic stuff,” she says.
The drift away was not a rupture. She calls it a slow burn. She began to struggle with her mental health in middle school, and by the end of high school, the Faith had moved from the center of her life to somewhere off to the side, and college finished the job. She wanted friends, as many as she could gather, and found community and fun at parties and in drinking. She kept going to Sunday Mass, however.
How did she square the two? “I could put Jesus on the shelf. I’ll take out my Jesus persona when I want to, and then when I’m done, I’ll put Him back.”
She met Nathan at a beach volleyball game, and while they attended Mass together, Anne recalls that God was not the center of their relationship. By sophomore year, she was drifting back to the Faith. She joined a discipleship group. She prayed more. She and Nathan were both moving in His direction, slowly, on their own schedule. Then a truck crossed the median.
A prayer in the wreckage
It was Dec. 27, 2020. Anne and Nathan, engaged by then, were driving home from Christmas with his family, westbound on I-90 between Sparta and Tomah, when a pickup heading the other direction hit black ice, fishtailed and crossed the median into their path. She saw it coming. There was nothing to be done. She closed her eyes and prayed the first fully honest prayer she had said in years: God, if You want to take me now, I’m ready.
The airbags took her out of consciousness before the noise stopped.
When she came back, the hood had been driven nearly to the dashboard, and the first thing she registered was not pain but the thick, acrid, chemical stink of burned rubber. Her back was broken, and she could not catch a full breath. First she asked Nathan whether he was all right.
He was, and was on the phone with 911. A man from another car had stopped at her window. Anne did not know what else to do, but she knew she needed to pray, and she began the Salve Regina.
A young woman who blocks on “Jesus” and “Catholic” and “baptism,” who has spent her life rerouting around her own vocabulary, was lying in a ruin of crushed metal, praying in Latin.
The man at her window heard a foreign language coming out of an injured stranger and drew what seemed the obvious conclusion: traumatic brain injury.
Something, the kidney or the fluid or the broken back, was pressing against her lungs, and she could not get the air to finish her prayer. “Nathan,” she said, “just say a Rosary or something.”
At the hospital, they found a dislocated and fractured back and a lacerated kidney. The fracture was unstable enough to require fusion surgery, and at first they feared that she might even be paralyzed. She was, her surgeon said, the luckiest person he would see that day. By the condition of the car, she could have been crushed. She would have chronic pain, he told her, for the rest of her life.
There He is
For a few weeks, she tried to be the person she had been before. The walker went away and the brace came off. Then came a Saturday morning, after a night of drinking, when three questions arrived and would not leave.
What am I doing? Where am I going? Am I okay with that?
She had seen the photographs of the car. She had been told she should have died in it. Her answers did not hold up against those facts.
She started going to daily Mass and to adoration at Blessed Sacrament Parish in La Crosse, sitting in front of the Crucifix. One day, the thing she had been circling arrived.
There He is. And here I am. We’re both in pain.
“When I first truly met Christ,” she says, “I met Him crucified.” She met God with a ruined body and recognized the condition.
What she did not have was a method. She knew Catholics were supposed to unite their suffering to Christ. She had no idea how a person actually did that on a Tuesday, with a back that hurt all day.
The answer arrived that summer, once she had healed enough to return to the job she had held through college. Anne opened a local ice cream parlor alone, early, before anyone else came in, which meant an hour of setting out rugs and running a vacuum with headphones on. That morning as she worked, she was listening to a podcast in which Father Josh Johnson talked about chronic pain and how to offer it to Christ. She stood in the empty shop and sobbed. Here was the how.
A church lady
The accident had done the same work on Anne and Nathan’s love. They placed Christ at the center of their relationship and married in September 2021.
She graduated that December with a degree in political science she no longer had any interest in using.
Then, a few days after Christmas, almost exactly a year after a pickup crossed the median on I-90, Anne attended a Mass in Wausau. The Gospel was the Presentation in the Temple, Simeon and Anna waiting in the dark for something promised. Father Joe Richards preached about his grandmother Helen, calling her a “church lady,”
a woman rooted in the Church and permanently available to the Holy Spirit.
Something in the phrase caught.
Anne realized, “I don’t know what God wants me to do, but whatever I do, I think
I want to be a church lady.”
Anne told no one, including Nathan, and did nothing about it for weeks. Speaking was not her charism. Speaking was the thing she had spent her life managing.
When the semester resumed, she went to Kristen, the woman she had been volunteering under in religious education for a few years, and asked whether they could talk. Kristen took her to lunch and spent an hour describing what the work actually entailed, and Anne decided to apply to be a parish director of religious education.
The bargain God never made
Underneath her yes to being a church lady was an assumption she had never examined: if God was calling her to stand in front of groups and proclaim His Word, He would make speaking easier while she did it.
It did not work that way. Public speaking makes a stutter worse, and hers got worse.
One of her first classes went badly enough that she went home wondering whether she had made the biggest mistake of her life. Her anxiety, which had recently been diagnosed as generalized anxiety disorder, took that fear and turned the volume up. Her mind, she says, can run fear up to 11 at any opportunity.
So, she asked God to heal her. Then begged. Then negotiated. God, I’m doing what You want. So, will You please just heal me? The case was not selfish, at least not as Anne built it. She could teach better. She could reach more young people. She could bring more souls to Christ, and wasn’t that the point?
Nothing changed.
“I was a little salty at that,” she says. Anne trusted God enough to be annoyed with Him out loud and to keep showing up. She kept teaching. She ran a youth group. She gave retreat talks. She discovered ways to manage her stutter more effectively, and although it never vanishes, there are now good days and bad days.
She went to therapy for her anxiety, and tells anyone who asks that she goes, because the stigma costs people years they do not need to lose. Her summary runs six words. “You need Jesus, and a therapist.” Prayer and therapy are not rival camps, and anxiety is not evidence of a deficient faith.
And then there was a night. It came after teaching and after youth group, at the end of a day when the stutter had been relentless and nothing had helped. She went into the church. It was dark, she was alone, and she stood in front of the Crucifix and said the thing she had been holding inside.
I thought that You would always be here for me.
Then she waited.
Asked what answer she received that night; she is quiet for a moment. “There was no answer.”
No consolation, no voice, no explanation of why God, who had called a woman to speak, would decline to make her speech flow smoothly. Just Anne, the Crucifix and an empty church.
“Sometimes there’s no clear answer,” she says. “It’s just an exercise in trust.”
Asked whether all of it has finally made trust one of her strengths, she does not hesitate, and she does not perform.
“I struggle with trust so badly.”
While everyone else sings
Here is what she does with the silence.
At Mass, during the presentation of the gifts, Anne does not sing. It is not that she dislikes the hymn. She is busy. She is sending her chronic back pain and all her other suffering up the aisle with the bread and wine, offered in union with Christ’s sacrifice for the salvation of souls and the reparation of sins. Each morning, she offers the whole day, everything in it that will hurt, before any of it has happened.
On Fridays, she does not keep it at all. Through Magdala Grove, Anne has committed every Friday to Father Timothy Reither and his ministry, spending her pain on his priesthood.
None of it makes her back hurt less, but it gives her somewhere to place it.
To be fixed
For most of her life, Anne carried a picture of a future self who would be the one God could really use. The current one was a draft. Ministry has taken that idea apart slowly.
Last year, she gave a confirmation retreat talk about peace and about the years she assumed peace was issued to other people, the ones whose minds did not run with the volume turned up too loud. Afterward, several students came to find her. One said that she had an anxiety disorder, too, and that hearing Anne talk about hers had made it make sense.
Inside that moment is a second thing Anne did not put there.
While she gave the talk, she was doing what she always does when she speaks: running half a sentence ahead of herself, listening for the next block, hunting an escape word, managing the mechanics of her own voice in real time.
She was listening to how she was speaking while they were listening to what she said.
She had spent years asking God to remove the stutter so she could reach more souls. She reached one without it being removed, in the middle of a talk she was privately fighting to get through. For that girl, the struggle was the message.
“God doesn’t want to encounter the potential me,” Anne says. “He works in the here and now, and He wants to encounter me as I am.”
Then, more simply: “I am not something to be fixed. I’m a person who’s called. And God does not call those who are perfect. He calls those whom He calls.”
Pressed on what she means, she reaches for Moses, who told God plainly that he was slow of speech and was sent anyway. Then, for a verse, she cites by chapter and verse without reaching for a Bible. Second Corinthians 4:7: We hold this treasure in earthen vessels, that the surpassing power may be of God and not from us.
“Being an earthen vessel means that I don’t have to be afraid,” she says. “I don’t have to fear my weaknesses, my failures or my brokenness, because Christ transforms them.”
None of which makes the wounds good. Her back needed surgery and got it. Her anxiety needs care and receives it. She would not object in the slightest if tomorrow brought less pain and easier speech. The Faith does not require anyone to call a wound good merely because God can work through it.
The stutter is not secretly a gift. The anxiety is not secretly a strength. Suggest otherwise, and she will correct you, then reach for St. Paul: all things work for the good of those who love God.
“I wouldn’t call them strengths in and of themselves,” she says. “I would say that I’m being strengthened through them.”
Nothing about her circumstances has changed. She still stutters in a job built entirely around speaking. She still manages generalized anxiety disorder with a therapist’s help. Her back still hurts every day and always will.
And some evenings, after the students have left and the building has gone quiet, she still walks into a dark church, looks up at a broken body hanging on a cross and asks where He is.
Sometimes nothing comes back.
She stays anyway.
She is not fixed. She is called.
