Each year, seniors attending the seven Catholic high schools in the Diocese of La Crosse write an essay of roughly 500 words analyzing a significant piece of literature. The students are given one class period, approximately 50 minutes, to complete their essay.
Essay Prompt: “Nineteen Eighty-Four” was written in 1948, shortly after World War II culminated in the establishment of the Soviet Empire throughout Eastern Europe. For the first time, the principles of socialism could be used to guarantee equality of outcomes for everyone. Equal pay for all jobs, no more rich capitalists enslaving workers, an end to the exploitation of women through bourgeois institutions like motherhood, etc. How does Orwell demonstrate that the happiness promised by social engineers cannot be achieved by sacrificing human nature and natural law?
“Nineteen Eighty-Four” and Truth
by Jordyn Jaglinski
In “Nineteen Eighty-Four”, George Orwell described a society where the government controls truth, history, and people’s thoughts. The system of INGSOC in the novel reflects many aspects of life under Joseph Stalin in the Soviet Union, where the state controlled information and punished those who disagreed with it. From a Catholic perspective, this type of system reveals the danger of trying to create a “perfect world” without God because it takes away a person’s human dignity and nature. Orwell’s novel shows that when a government attempts to control the society-like Stalin’s government-it destroys truth, rewrites the past, and manipulates human nature which contradicts the Catholic understanding of freedom, morality, and human dignity of a person.
The main way that the Party controls society is by controlling truth and rewriting history. Winston works in the Ministry of Truth where he changes books and magazines to what the Party agrees to. Orwell reflects Stalin’s Russia, where newspapers and books were rewritten and even “nonexistent persons” were removed from history. Under Stalin, many members of the Party were executed such as those associated with Lubyanka–and their existence was erased. In today’s world, technology and computers (AI) could make this kind of manipulation even easier. From a Catholic perspective, truth cannot be changed by those in power because truth comes from God and must remain constant.
Another way the Party controls the society is by manipulating human nature. The Party controls people by the telescreen, watching their every move and looking to find people that commit thoughtcrime. This sense of control shows how limited society can be, especially when they have no control or freedom. Like Stalin’s Russia, the people who disagreed with Stalin or thought of him as nothing more than any other person were killed and executed. People did not have a choice of expressing their own thoughts or what they believed. As Winston states, “it was even slightly dangerous to go on a walk alone.” This kind of imprisonment is what the Party wanted. They wanted to take away people’s reason and limit words, like the Newspeak dictionary, in order to take away all power that wasn’t already theirs. The only ones who the Party did not care about were the proles but as we see by the end of the book, all they wanted was money and luck especially in jackpots. From the Catholic point of view, this takes away all human freedom which is the will that God gifted each and every one of us. Sacrificing human nature destroys all truth because God created the Truth and without that we are all in trouble.
The Party controlled the society by sacrificing natural law which is the truth of right and wrong that every society and person knows. When Winston was kept in prison, the Party controlled his mind by teaching him what to believe by violence and torture. One of the things that they taught was two plus two equals five. At first, Winston kept saying four based on the objective truth and scientific reasoning. But the Party took away his scientific knowledge by repeating it to Winston over and over again. He soon became intellectually progressive but still not emotionally. So they took him into Room 101 and found a way for him to betray Julia for himself to live. At this moment, Winston knew that he lost all of his natural moral law and was now at the hands of the Big Brother. Something reminded me of the quote from “Hamlet” saying, “There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt in your philosophy.” Shakespeare agreed that scientific learning could not explain everything. But when you take away a person’s reason for right and wrong, you can soon control the way a person thinks. The Party did not understand that destroying all moral truth, you destroy human nature and all you have left are animals with no intellect or will. Think of what you would do if you were the only human on the planet and everyone else were animals. It would be hard to find much happiness in life for both you and the animals themselves. Once the Party destroyed society, no happiness was left including human nature and natural law.
“Nineteen Eighty-Four” shows the dangers of trying to create a society through complete control of society. By rewriting history, controlling language, and manipulating human nature, the Party in Orwell’s novel mirrors many aspects of Stalin’s Russian communist system. From a Catholic perspective, the novel demonstrates that a society without God cannot respect human dignity or human nature. Orwell warns us that without the truth of God and natural moral law, society and life in general could become pointless. A society without God could not be called a society at all. The thought and ideology of a perfect world becomes a society of fear and lies. This society is closer to becoming real in our own world due to technology and AI. We must know the truth of God and hang on to our human nature in order to survive.

